Toys & Stuffed Animals: Everything Goes in the Mouth. Everything.
Babies chew everything. The remote, your keys, the dog's ear (sorry, dog). So toy materials matter as much as play value. Here's the stuff that's safe to chew, cuddle, and throw across the room.
The short version: what actually matters
- Natural rubber for bath and teething toys — soft, chewable, plant-based. And check bath toys have no holes where water (and mold) hides inside.
- Organic cotton for stuffed animals — the ones your baby sleeps with should be organic cotton, not polyester fill.
- Solid wood for rattles and play sets — holds up, cleans easily, doesn't shed plastic.
- BPA-free and plastic-free where possible.
- Age-appropriate is a safety check, not a suggestion. Small parts are the real test — match the toy to the age on the label.
Soft & cuddly — the good stuff
Petit Collage Organic Busy Bear Activity Toy — $25.00 Handmade organic teddy with gentle developmental activities. The one in the header photo — and the one that'll be in every family photo.
COTTONEBEBE Organic Stuffed Bunny with Lullaby Music, Mrs. Bunny — $25.49 Organic, plays lullabies, for infants 0–36 months. A bunny that sings your baby to sleep. Enough said.
Organic Cotton Baby First Friend, Hello! Little Bunny — $24.95 Organic attachment doll and pillow buddy, 15.7 inches tall. The lovey.
Super Soft Organic Cotton Baby First Friend, Honey Baby Tiger — $24.95 Same idea, tiger edition. For the baby who prefers stripes.
CUDDLE CORNER Bunny Stuffed Animal, Organic Cotton, 7" — $24.99 Soft, cuddly, organic cotton. Travel-size lovey.
Organic Elephant Lovey, Muslin Security Blanket, Khaki — $15.29 Muslin snuggle toy and security blanket. The cheapest cuddle on the page.
Bath & teething — the good stuff
HEVEA Kawan Mini Rubber Duck, Eggnog — $19.99 100% natural rubber, mold-free, for playing, teething, and bathing. The duck, but make it non-toxic.
HEVEA Squeeze'n'Splash Whale Bath Toy — $22.00 100% natural rubber, plant-based, plastic-free, BPA-free.
AMCHSURI Mold Free Animal Bath Toys, 9-Pack — $15.99 No-hole bathtub toys, eco-friendly, for infants 6–12 months. Nine toys, zero mold. That's the whole pitch.
Nuby Jackie The Giraffe Teether with Squeaker — $12.98 100% natural rubber, super soft. Giraffes: nature's teether shape, apparently.
Arudyo Silicone Teethers with Wooden Ring, Khaki — $7.99 BPA-free silicone with a wooden ring. The cheapest teether here, and it works.
Moonkie Stacks of Circles Soft Teething Toy, 7-Piece — $13.99 Stacking rings that double as teethers. Two jobs, one toy.
HEVEA Upcycled Star Ball — $21.99 100% upcycled natural rubber, plant-based, plastic-free, BPA-free, FDA approved.
Play & learning — the good stuff
Wooden Baby Rattle 3-Piece Push Car Set, Rabbit Rattle — $19.99 Crochet rattle ring, wooden Montessori toy for newborns.
Melissa & Doug Wooden Scoop and Serve Ice Cream Counter, 28 pcs — $35.99 Pretend ice cream shop, ages 3 and up. The toy that turns your toddler into a small business owner.
Melissa & Doug Wooden Take-Along Barn Toy — $20.39 Flip-up roof, handle, 10 farm pieces, shape sorting, ages 2 and up.
Melissa & Doug Wooden Slice & Stack Sandwich Counter, 56 pcs — $41.99 Pretend deli with a slicer. 56 pieces. You will step on at least one. Worth it.
Melissa & Doug Let's Play House Dust! Sweep! Mop! 6-Piece Set — $27.97 Pretend cleaning set. The only time anyone in the house will volunteer to mop.
See the full list, with links, on our Toys page: https://www.nontoxicbabies.com/product-categories/toys-stuffed-animals
The 2am test
Under one? Start with a natural rubber teether and one organic cotton lovey — those two get chewed and cuddled every day. For bath time, no-hole toys are the ones that stay mold-free. Wooden and cloth toys outlast plastic ones and clean easier, so they're the better spend once your baby starts really playing.
As an Amazon Associate, NontoxicBabies.com earns from qualifying purchases made through links on this site.